The Finch Formerly Known As Gold

16 February 2004

A crock of discs now

This oughta be good: Writer (and iconoclast) Dawn Eden has signed on to do a piece for Kill Your Idols: A New Generation of Rock Writers Reconsiders the Classics, a compilation due this summer from editor (and iconoclast) Jim DeRogatis. The premise is simple enough: are all those revered rock classics of yore deserving of reverence?

In a word, no. Even works I dearly love, like Pet Sounds, have their detractors, and as we all know, it's far more fun to be snarky than to be solemn. Eden is taking on Brian Wilson's oft-bootlegged but officially-unreleased Smile, and from the bits and pieces I've heard over the years, I suspect there's a darn good reason, beyond Wilson's raging pathologies of the moment, that this stuff has stayed in the can. I'm definitely looking forward to this compilation, even as I contemplate the possibility that some of my sacred cows will end up as Quarter Pounders with Cheese.

Posted at 7:49 AM to Tongue and Groove


Good god, I hope she finally puts that whole "Beatles are All" crap to rest.

Everyone knows - KNOWS - that the Monkees (and Beach Boys) were & are infinitely better.

Posted by: David at 5:20 PM on 16 February 2004