The Finch Formerly Known As Gold

28 February 2004

Standards of proof

"President Bush," writes Brian Brus in the Oklahoma Gazette, "recently has had a hard time proving his whereabouts in 1972 to the satisfaction of political opponents. Even after the White House released military records from his service in the Texas Air National Guard, some still questioned whether he completed his military duty and unfavorably compared his wartime service to that of his likely Democratic presidential opponent, decorated combat veteran John Kerry."

What does it take to prove one's whereabouts? Brus hit up a number of public figures in Oklahoma and demanded, "Where were you in '72?"

Governor Henry wasn't in the military at all; in fact, reports press secretary Phil Bacharach, he was in the fourth grade at Sequoyah Elementary School in Shawnee, and he has the report cards to prove it.

Former governor George Nigh was in the Navy in the middle Forties, but where was he in 1972? "I was lieutenant governor of Oklahoma," he said. Asked if he could document this claim, Nigh asserted: "I'm sure there's some sort of travel voucher I turned in."

Should anyone ask, I was in the Army for most of 1972, and I still have copies of orders and payroll forms if anyone needs to verify this.

Posted at 5:30 PM to Soonerland


Bush has his orders and payroll records, too. That doesn't seem to be enough proof for McAwful and his ilk.

Posted by: Ralph Gizzip at 6:27 PM on 28 February 2004

Precisely the point. It doesn't matter what documentation is produced; they're trying to create just enough doubt to impress people who don't pay attention.

Posted by: CGHill at 6:41 PM on 28 February 2004

Maybe Bush was in a cellar somewhere erasing 16 minutes off a tape.

I'm just saying.

Posted by: Vickie at 7:48 AM on 29 February 2004

I was in the fourth grade, beginning the years-long process of leaving my inherited Democrat leanings by rejecting McGovern.

Posted by: McGehee at 8:59 AM on 29 February 2004

I was stationed at MCAS Iwakuni, Japan in 72 and then transfered to the naval base a Yokuska, Japan at the end of the year. I was busy dogding the draft as you can see. These democrats can get a little ridiculous at times.

Posted by: anstranger at 4:21 PM on 1 March 2004