The Finch Formerly Known As Gold

11 March 2006

Fatuous Flashback 24

"Rock is dead," said Dean Esmay, which prompted this postmortem:

[A]s one of those hated Baby Boomers, I run the risk that anything I say on the subject will be interpreted as an expression of proprietary interest, yet another example of how, um, my generation still thinks it rules the goddamn world even as it teeters on its walkers on the way to the grave.

Still, almost anyone of any age beyond twenty-five or so believes somewhere in his heart of hearts that everything that's been inflicted on us by the music industry since he got out of college truly and deeply sucks, and neither Dean nor I is immune to this notion. My own thinking is that when we're younger, the music isn't just the soundtrack to our existence: it's woven into the fabric of our selves, and cannot be separated without unraveling everything that we know, everything that we are. As we get older, more settled, maybe less emotional, the music recedes somewhat into the background: we take note of it, we may even be fond of it, but it isn't part of us anymore.

The music industry has aided and abetted this situation by fragmenting itself beyond all understanding. In the Sixties, there were maybe half a dozen music formats on the radio. Today, there are genres, subgenres, even sub-subgenres — does anyone other than a radio consultant know the exact point where CHR/Pop ends and CHR/Rhythmic begins? — all motivated by desperation in the guise of "research." Inevitably, this rush toward differentiation ultimately repels the audience; except for a few 12-year-olds of varying ages, people's musical tastes span a range far wider than anything you'll hear on any single radio station, commercial or otherwise. And so we push another button, and another consultant is hired to explain why, and the cycle repeats. (Not even classical stations are immune to this, as anyone who has heard me grumble, "Jeez, Saint-Saëns' Organ Symphony again?" can testify.)

(From "Two days burying the cat", 14 March 2004.)

Posted at 8:56 AM to Greatest Hits


This is true. I still have most of my rock records from my period of musical heat, back in the 70s and 80s, which I once thought I simply could not live without. Some of the records I used to listen over and over so obsessively that they are fairly unplayable now. But now I hardly ever listen to them.

Posted by: Andrea Harris at 9:44 AM on 11 March 2006

"Still, almost anyone of any age beyond twenty-five or so believes somewhere in his heart of hearts that everything that's been inflicted on us by the music industry since he got out of college truly and deeply sucks..."

Not I. My favorite bands were all born well after I left college: Glass Hammer, Spock's Beard, The Flower Kings, and Tangent.

Some of us do remain open to new music. Of course, there's also "rap," which should begin with a C and be punished by law, but that's another screed.

Posted by: Francis W. Porretto at 3:52 PM on 11 March 2006

I've actually never gotten out of college (I did one year of community college after high school, realized that was like more high school, quit for years, went back, quit, went back, quit, rinse, repeat five or so times, finally got my associates degree in 2001, did some work towards my bachelors, quit...) -- anyway, I didn't do that traditional four years of college thing, so the College Years as Formative Experience isn't part of mine. But by the time I graduated high school punk had come and already gone stale -- leaving most of Miami untouched in its obsession with disco OR REO Speedwagon/Journey/Led Zeppelin/Rush -- and I didn't get into any contemporary music until New Wave came out. (Before I had been into sixties music almost exclusively.)

Posted by: Andrea Harris at 7:38 PM on 11 March 2006