Conflicting stories have arisen in the Erick Williamson case, though the basic facts of the incident seem clear: the guy was having a cuppa joe in his birthday suit, and someone saw him and raised holy hell.
Now to me, this is risky behavior: what if he sloshes the stuff around? Burn City.
Michele Catalano wrote the story up for PJM:
Whether it’s something simple like smoking during dinner (outlawed in most public places) or something less innocent involving nudity and preferably our partner or spouse, we feel safe and protected in our house — or at least we should, presuming the activity isn’t criminal.
But nosy people and prudish neighbors think that if they wouldn’t do it, you shouldn’t be doing it either. Maybe most of us close the drapes if we’re walking around in just our skin, but we don’t have to — no such law exists. I’m sure it did not cross Williamson’s mind, as he walked into the kitchen and reached for the coffee pot, that a woman would be walking her kid across his lawn and looking in his window.
I wouldn’t be too sure that “no such law exists”: laws vary, often wildly, from one jurisdiction to the next. Lisa Paul, who often comments here, has noted:
You do have fewer rights to privacy in your own home than you may think. If his window is visible from a well travelled walkway or thoroughfare and a photographer were to stand on public land and take his picture nude at the coffee pot, that would probably be legal. Now disseminating that picture probably wouldn’t be.
As is often the case these days, I’m fairly well torn here. Certainly I defend anyone’s right to be nude on his own property; on the other hand, one should not annoy the neighbors unnecessarily. Then again, it’s difficult to see into my house from the street, regardless of the position of the drapes and the blinds, because of topography and foliage: you have to be at exactly the right angle, and if you blink you’ll miss it.
And Eric Scheie sees the sexism inherent in the system:
[I]f I were to cut through someone’s yard … and see a guy naked inside, I’d feel a little ashamed of myself for invading his privacy. It would never, ever, in my wildest dreams occur to me to call the cops, and I would expect to be laughed (or worse) at if I did. If I saw a naked woman, I’d run, for I would expect her to call the cops. And if I saw a naked adolescent girl, I’d run even faster, lest I be accused by her mother of stalking a child.
While none of this is fair, it’s the way the world works.
In the best of all possible worlds, or even a few steps down from there, this would all be infinitely yawn-worthy: “Oh, he doesn’t have any clothes on. Big deal.” But in this Era of Umbrage, nothing is ever shrugged off by anyone for any reason.