The Finch Formerly Known As Gold

14 October 2006

The Curtis Mathes syndrome

Dave Dial, a former Oklahoman transplanted to Los Angeles forty-odd years ago, explained this to me, and it rang truer than I'd prefer to admit:

When a consumer buys a contraption that combines two or more functions, if one of them breaks down and is too expensive or inconvenient to repair, the consumer will typically continue to use the parts that still work. So we see combination telephone-answering machines where the answering machine has crapped out but the phone still works and is still in use. We see those cute little combination TV-VCRs where the VCR's mechanism has eaten one tape too many but the TV still works, to give two examples.

I based the syndrome on observing back in the 1960s that many homes had what was called a "home entertainment center": a huge, living-room-space-consuming combination television-radio-phonograph with the TV dead but the radio and phonograph still working. Besides, it was a good-looking piece of furniture. Too bad there was no money to fix the TV but enough to buy a much cheaper table model set that might even be placed directly on top of the partially-defunct home entertainment center.

Besides, a lot of those humongous consoles had old B&W sets in them; if not necessarily more cost-effective, it was a lot more appealing to buy a color set and park it on top, and if you were lucky enough to have one of the high-end consoles with a picture tube that hid behind sliding doors or louvers, no one need ever know your dark, deep secret.

Actual Curtis Mathes consoles probably suffered less from this syndrome than some other, better-known brands: the tiny Texas-based manufacturer's long-running slogan was "The most expensive television in America, and darn well worth it," and they meant it. But by the 1960s, parts were relatively cheap, and labor relatively expensive; if you were unwilling to mess around with the high-voltage innards of a television, you either wrote a large check or bought a new set. (This reality was ultimately reflected in the Curtis Mathes warranty: one year on labor, ten years on parts, still in effect when I bought one of their sets in 1981. I wrote about the experience here. That set, incidentally, was still working when I donated it to Goodwill in 2002, though the picture was a little greener than spec.)

I know the syndrome well, though. I had replaced the original factory radio in my old Toyota Celica with a radio/cassette unit. Eventually, the tape mechanism quit working, in a truly fascinating fashion: the transport had somehow locked itself into a position where it thought there was a tape already in there, which meant (1) you couldn't insert an actual tape and (2) it automatically cut off the radio. Faced with the possibility of having to crawl back under the dash and replace the factory unit, or buy a whole new stereo, I shoved a plastic dowel (actually part of an old Bic pen barrel) just far enough into the tape transport to defeat the radio-off switch, which left me with a dead tape unit but a working radio. This ad hoc fix lasted six years, two years longer than the duct-tape job on the exhaust manifold. (Don't ask.)

Conversely, I once had a fairly crummy $200 shelf-unit stereo whose turntable failed, which I replaced with a real live Dual 1215 hi-fi unit, thereby guaranteeing myself high-quality reproduction right up to the point where the signal entered the amplifier. In automotive terms, this is dropping a 351 Cleveland into a Kia Sephia.

Posted at 7:24 PM to Dyssynergy


We had one of those home-entertainment thingies when I was a kid. Actually, back then it was called a "hi-fi system." It had a black and white tv built in -- I think it was a 20 inch screen too, which was big in those days -- an am radio -- I don't remember if it had fm then, I don't think it did -- and a record player that had 4 speeds -- 16, 33, 45, and 78. My parents had some old Big Band 78s that they would listen to, and I did have one record (from the back of a cereal box, I think) that you had to play at 16 rpm.

The tv was the first thing to go. Then the radio died. The record player lasted the longest. And it sounded great -- I used to play my Renaissance albums on it when my parents would let me, and there was nothing like blasting "Midas Man" on a state-of-the-art stereo system. Of course we kept the thing even after the record player component finally died, and used it like a console table. It was too heavy to move.

Posted by: Andrea Harris at 8:48 PM on 14 October 2006

Too heavy to move is easy enough to solve. We got rid of such a rig recently with the help of a chain saw (but just the little electric one).

As to Kia engine swaps, the smart move is to go to the Mazda catalog. Altho now owned by Hyundai, which uses Mitsubishi technology, Kia is still building Mazda clones, and there is surely a 4valve turbo version of whichever engine is in the Sephia.

Posted by: triticale at 7:30 AM on 15 October 2006

Sephias generally had a 1.8-liter DOHC four based on the MX-5/Miata block; I would think that even the stock BP engine from those days might be an improvement over Kia's own mill.

Posted by: CGHill at 10:28 AM on 15 October 2006

Man, I was so poor that our "home entertainment system" only had a TV in the console.

Well okay, it was a 25" color TV, but still...

Anybody know why console TVs went the way of the Betamax? I was wondering about that not too long ago.

Posted by: McGehee at 11:22 AM on 15 October 2006

I'd guess it was the manifest desire of the customers to house all those separate audio components together with the TV set in a single, difficult-to-assemble rack unit.

Posted by: CGHill at 11:51 AM on 15 October 2006