The Finch Formerly Known As Gold

14 January 2007

Geek girl shoots back

One of the more exasperating aspects of contemporary culture is its occasional insistence on credentials of dubious utility. Reb offers this example:

One guy said, word for word, "If you really like Batman, name three Robins." Because hey, I'm me, I busted out Stephanie Brown, in fact, and not Tim Drake. I was then told that I’d forgotten one. ("No, you asked for three and I named three. If you wanted Tim, you should have asked who the three male Robins were.") I was asked who killed Jason Todd. I was asked to detail current storylines.

And again, keep in mind, these were questions to establish that, good god, I really was a living, breathing girl — an attractive one, no less! — who was into something nerdy. One of the guys responded with wonder. The other, who many women at the store have had other, far worse kinds of run ins with, was angry and condescending. (Needless to say, he was the one who hadn't even realized Stephanie was a valid answer to the Robin question.) This all went on for a good twenty minutes (until our break ended, in fact) and through the whole thing I got more flustered and more angry, though I couldn't quite put my finger on why until later.

I later pondered and realized that what pissed me off was the notion that, because I'm female, I need to prove to men that I can join their exclusive club. And once that proof is established, I'm still not really allowed into their clubhouse. In the same way that so many nerds consider jocks to be practically another species, well, women are, too. We are Other. We're confusing and mystifying. And it doesn't matter if we like the same things, if we read the same things, if we discuss the same things. 'Female' is 'Other'. But a female who is into those same things is put into yet another classification — as both female and nerd (especially if you’re attractive) you're now a fetish. You're someone who can share the joy of videogames and comics and science fiction, so he doesn't have to alter his interests to impress you — and on top of that, you might have sex with him. You're not just a girl, you're a dream girl.

Yea, verily. I have a slight tendency toward geekiness, a greater one toward nerdity, and I cherish the few geek/nerd girls I know, but as a general rule, I'm not about to ask one of them to prove herself, as it were: if they have the spirit, it shows easily enough. (And besides, I'm more Marvel than DC; I'd have missed the Robin question.)

My immediate reaction, I must confess, was not so measured; it was more like "So who died and left them in charge of Geek Points?" The very definition of geekitude provides that sooner or later, more likely sooner, it comes out; it's about as useful as asking nuns if they ever thought about, you know, God and stuff. And I am quite vigorously opposed to grilling a possible date, unless you plan to pop the question that very night, in which case may I suggest that maybe you're going a little too fast for your own good.

Apparently, though, Reb's experience is not universal — at least, I hope it's not. For instance:

I am a fairly attractive female, I prefer sci-fi/fantasy to almost any other genre (book, tv, and movie); I loved reading the Sandman and Watchmen comics/graphic novels (not much of a comic reader anymore); I love new gadgets (and used to have a garage full of outdated computer equipment — before eBay); I have worked in technology for 14+ years (sometimes being the only female in the entire department); I play video games (as a matter of fact I used to hang out in arcades to actually play the games); and I have never even once had anyone (male or female) even insinuate that I needed to prove my geek status.

Nor should she have. True geek, like other positive characteristics, will present itself on its own schedule.

Posted at 6:47 PM to Table for One


I did read comics at one point in time but they were usually Archie's. I think Betty had the most potential to be a geek.

Posted by: Diane at 4:35 AM on 15 January 2007

Try being a somewhat geeky girl who has to make a living as a Subject Matter Expert in my career field.

Oy vey!

Posted by: Tam at 8:35 AM on 15 January 2007

Sadly, geekiness tends to out us whether we want it too or not. I just gave up and embraced my inner geek long ago.

Posted by: "Orange Mike" Lowrey at 3:43 PM on 16 January 2007

i hate it when im chatting to a guy, and ill like him a little than he goes and starts explaining something so simple "cos im a girl" it annoys me so much i tend to ignore there existance from than on XD further im a high school student, and i have teachers patronising my ability because im female, they think i have never been to a lan or programed anything! i thinkn its about time female geeks and nerds are recognised for what we are!

Posted by: heather at 12:49 AM on 30 January 2007