The Finch Formerly Known As Gold

30 August 2007

Still groovin'

No-longer-Young Rascal Gene Cornish talked to his old hometown newspaper this week, and he touches on one issue that's always nagged at me:

The [Rascals'] first four albums are being released with both stereo and mono versions on each CD, so audiophiles can compare and argue. "The mono mix is so far superior to the stereo mix," Cornish insists. "Stereo was in its infancy back then. No one knew how to mike anything."

I don't know if I'd call it "infancy" or not — stereo recordings started to appear in quantity around 1958, a good eight years before Gene and the boys got their first big hits — but I suspect he's right about no one knowing how to mike things. The Rascals did enough of their own production to earn label credit, alongside Atlantic stalwarts Tom Dowd and Arif Mardin, but this was still the era of the 45, and the mono single mix was the one that counted. "Good Lovin'," the band's second single and first Number One, sounds particularly heinous in stereo. While the instrumental mix isn't too awful for a period piece, Felix Cavaliere's lead vocal is panned back and forth between the channels: the opening "One, two, three!" ping-pongs back and forth, and in the second verse, the voice changes sides in the middle of a syllable. Ask me my opinion, my opinion will be: get the reissues with the mono mixes — or see if you can find an original 45.

One other cool thing about the Rascals, now that I'm thinking about them: their publishing company was called "Slacsar," which is "Rascals" spelled backwards, the sort of thing you didn't see too often. (Eric Burdon's second group of Animals had a publishing unit called "Slamina.") And I never have decided which Rascals track was my favorite: it's either "You Better Run," a stomper with a growling Gene Cornish guitar riff, or "How Can I Be Sure," an atypical Eddie Brigati lead in waltz time, of all things.

Posted at 7:23 PM to Tongue and Groove


the mono single mix was the one that counted.

This being still the heyday of AM music radio. Does the rise of FM music radio correspond closely (as logic would suggest) to the producers figuring out how to "mike" for it?

Posted by: McGehee at 9:42 PM on 30 August 2007

Mmmm, the Rascals. I'll never forget buying their "Timepeace" greatest hits record back in 1980 or so, and being amazed at the quality of two songs I'd never heard before: "How Can I Be Sure", and "It's a Beautiful Morning".

These guys could write, and sing, and as you note, the production weren't too bad, neither.

Posted by: Jeff Brokaw at 10:26 PM on 30 August 2007

Actually, the development of FM rock was largely the product of an FCC decree requiring that stations in the top markets program their AM and FM outlets separately, rather than simply simulcasting. (Said rule has since been ditched, mostly out of fear that the AMs might fold.)

Posted by: CGHill at 7:00 AM on 31 August 2007