Sensibly enough, Doc Searls chose to repair the old buggy rather than buy a new one:
A few days ago I took in my old Volkswagen Passat to get the water pump replaced. Turns out lots of other stuff was worn out or broken and needed fixing too. The final bill came to around $5000, which is what I paid for the thing three years ago.
For a minute I thought about getting a new car. They’re cheaper than ever, with lots of good deals, and guarantees that would relieve me of the need to pay much for upkeep. But I decided to fix the old car instead, because it’s good enough. Spending $5k is better than spending $20k, especially if I don’t have to borrow the difference.
I can endorse this premise: I can buy a whole lot of maintenance for Gwendolyn’s original $31,000 sticker — or, for that matter, with the 70 percent of it the previous owner had to eat in depreciation.
I’m not so sure, though, that he’s spotted a major trend here:
New car purchases are impelled mostly by advertising and fantasy. Drive a lot of rental cars and you get hip to the obvious: the differences between cars, especially fairly new ones, isn’t large.
Now, what happens if an absence of new car fantasy prevails for the duration? What if the whole automobile business has jumped the shark, and the problem isn’t just Detroit’s?
If you view a car as primarily a means to get from Point A to Point B without having to ride the M.T.A., then yes, they’re all fairly interchangeable. I don’t think Searls himself fully subscribes to this notion, if only because, in my experience anyway, people with this viewpoint tend not to drive Passats, which offer a sort-of-premium driving experience at a sort-of-premium price. (As always, your mileage may vary.) I would not at all be surprised to hear, though, that others have reached this conclusion on their own, bruised by four-dollar-plus gas or five-grand repair bills, and vowing never to go down that road again.
We do, however, expect a lot more from our cars than we used to, and the level of standard equipment has grown tremendously: air conditioning is now pretty much universal, as is the stereo sound system with CD player, as is the multiplicity of air bags. There are times when I think that there aren’t any handy automotive gadgets yet to devise. And then here comes a Ford Flex with a fridge, or any number of wagons with backup cameras, and I have to admit I’m wrong again. Tyranny of the new, to be sure; but I don’t think we’re going to conquer vehicular lust in my lifetime. Not mine, anyway.